Is CafePress Safe to Order From? Addressing Security Concerns

Is CafePress Safe to Order From? Addressing Security Concerns

by

Navigating the world of online shopping can be tricky, especially when it comes to security. If you’ve been considering ordering from CafePress, a popular platform for custom merchandise, you might have stumbled upon some concerning search results regarding “is cafepress safe,” “cafepress safe to order,” or even “cafepress scam.” These searches understandably raise questions about the platform’s security. In this blog post, we’ll delve into CafePress’s past security issues, the actions taken by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and what you need to know to make an informed decision about ordering from the platform.

Table of Contents:

CafePress’s Past Security Issues

CafePress faced a major security breach in 2019 that exposed a significant amount of user data. Hackers gained access to millions of email addresses, passwords, and personal information. Disturbingly, over 180,000 unencrypted Social Security numbers were also compromised in the breach. The security flaws that allowed this breach to occur were numerous, including the storage of sensitive information like Social Security numbers in plain text, inadequate password encryption, and a failure to adequately respond to security warnings and vulnerabilities.

CafePress’s response to the breach raised further concerns. The company was aware of the breach for months before notifying affected customers, even after being warned by a foreign government. This delayed response and lack of transparency contributed to the data being sold on the dark web, leaving users vulnerable to identity theft and other risks.

To make matters worse, this wasn’t the first time CafePress had faced security issues. There were prior instances of users having their accounts hacked, and the company had a policy of charging shopkeepers a fee to close these compromised accounts. These past practices, coupled with the 2019 data breach, painted a worrying picture of CafePress’s commitment to user security.

The FTC’s Action and Proposed Settlement

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the agency responsible for protecting consumers from unfair or deceptive business practices, took action against CafePress due to these security failures and deceptive practices. The FTC’s complaint highlighted several issues:

  • Inadequate Data Security: CafePress failed to implement basic security measures, such as encrypting sensitive information and using strong password protection.
  • Concealment of the Breach: The company knowingly concealed the 2019 breach for an extended period, neglecting to conduct a proper investigation and delaying customer notifications.
  • Deceptive Practices: CafePress misled customers about the use of their email addresses for marketing purposes.

To address these violations, the FTC proposed a settlement that mandates several important changes:

  • Financial Compensation: Residual Pumpkin Entity, LLC, the former owner of CafePress, will pay $500,000 to compensate users affected by the data breaches.
  • Comprehensive Security Program: PlanetArt, LLC, the company that acquired CafePress in 2020, and Residual Pumpkin must implement a comprehensive information security program to prevent future breaches. This includes:
    • Multi-factor Authentication: Implementing multi-factor authentication to enhance login security.
    • Data Encryption: Encrypting all sensitive user information, particularly Social Security numbers.
    • Minimizing Data Collection and Retention: Limiting data collection to what is absolutely necessary and securely deleting data that is no longer needed.
  • Consumer Notification and Guidance: Affected consumers must be notified about the breach, and the companies must provide guidance on how to protect themselves from identity theft.
  • Independent Security Assessment: A third-party assessor will evaluate the security programs of both PlanetArt and Residual Pumpkin. A redacted version of this assessment will be made public, promoting transparency and accountability.

Current State of CafePress Security

Since the 2019 breach and acquisition by PlanetArt, CafePress is under legal obligation to improve its security practices. The FTC settlement mandates a series of changes that are designed to prevent future breaches and protect user data. PlanetArt is required to implement a comprehensive information security program that addresses the flaws that led to the previous breach.

However, it’s important to remember that no company is entirely immune to data breaches. The threat landscape is constantly evolving, and hackers are becoming more sophisticated. While CafePress is making efforts to improve its security, users should remain vigilant about their online security and take steps to protect themselves.

Tips for Safe Ordering on CafePress (and in general)

While the past security issues with CafePress are concerning, it’s important to understand that data breaches are, unfortunately, a common occurrence in today’s digital landscape. Here are some tips to help you stay safe when ordering on CafePress and other online platforms:

  • Use Strong, Unique Passwords: Create strong passwords that are at least 12 characters long and include a mix of upper and lowercase letters, numbers, and symbols. Avoid using the same password for multiple accounts.
  • Enable Multi-Factor Authentication: Whenever possible, enable multi-factor authentication for your CafePress and other online accounts. This adds an extra layer of security by requiring a unique code from your phone or email in addition to your password.
  • Be Cautious About Sharing Information: Limit the amount of personal information you share online, especially sensitive information like your Social Security number. Only provide what is absolutely necessary for your transaction.
  • Monitor Your Accounts: Regularly review your bank statements and credit card statements for any suspicious activity. If you notice any unauthorized transactions, report them to your bank or credit card issuer immediately.
  • Stay Informed About Security: Keep up-to-date on the latest security threats and best practices for protecting yourself online. The FTC website is a valuable resource for consumer security information.

FAQ Section

Given the search results you found about “is cafepress safe,” “cafepress safe to order,” and “cafepress scam,” you likely have a few pressing questions. Let’s address some of the most common concerns:

  • Is CafePress a scam? CafePress is a legitimate business that sells custom merchandise. However, its past security shortcomings raise valid concerns.
  • Can I trust CafePress with my credit card information? CafePress uses encryption to secure payment information during transactions. Look for security indicators like HTTPS in the website address bar to ensure a secure connection.
  • What should I do if my CafePress account was compromised in the 2019 breach? If you believe your account was affected by the breach, visit the FTC website for guidance on protecting yourself from identity theft. They offer comprehensive resources for data breach victims.
  • Has CafePress improved its security since the breach? The FTC settlement legally mandates PlanetArt, the current owner of CafePress, to implement a comprehensive security program, which should lead to improvements. However, it’s always wise to exercise caution with your online data.

Conclusion

CafePress has undoubtedly faced significant security challenges in the past, which understandably raise concerns about the safety of ordering from the platform. However, the FTC’s action and the subsequent settlement with PlanetArt offer a glimmer of hope for improved security. While it’s always essential to be vigilant about your online safety, the mandated security enhancements, including multi-factor authentication and data encryption, have the potential to make CafePress a safer platform for users. Remember to take proactive steps to protect your personal information, and continue to monitor the situation to make informed decisions about your online shopping.