Squarespace vs. BigCommerce vs. Shopify: Which Website Builder Reigns Supreme?

Squarespace vs. BigCommerce vs. Shopify: Which Website Builder Reigns Supreme?

by

Choosing the right e-commerce platform is the foundation for building a successful online business. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. Three of the most popular contenders frequently top the list: Squarespace, BigCommerce, and Shopify. When it comes to searches like “bigcommerce vs squarespace,” “shopify vs squarespace vs bigcommerce,” “bigcommerce vs shopify vs squarespace,” and even “shopify vs wix vs bigcommerce,” these platforms consistently dominate the results.

This blog post will break down the key features, pros, and cons of these platforms, equipping you with the knowledge to choose the perfect platform for your unique needs.

Table of Contents

Platform Overview

Let’s begin with a high-level overview of each platform:

Squarespace

  • Target audience: Squarespace appeals to creatives, businesses emphasizing aesthetics, and those with brick-and-mortar stores seeking an online presence.
  • Key features: Squarespace stands out with its sleek, professionally designed templates and its all-in-one platform approach. It includes hosting, domain registration, e-commerce functionalities, and robust blogging features, all in one package. Squarespace also shines with its built-in tools for invoicing, payroll, and taxes, making it particularly attractive to businesses with physical locations.

BigCommerce

  • Target audience: BigCommerce is ideal for growing businesses, those with large product catalogs, and established online retailers seeking a powerful and scalable platform.
  • Key features: BigCommerce is known for its robust built-in e-commerce features and functionalities. It offers a wide array of tools right out of the box, minimizing the need for third-party app integrations. A major draw for BigCommerce is the absence of transaction fees on any of its plans, unlike some competitors. It’s also designed to handle businesses of all sizes, making scalability a key advantage.

Shopify

  • Target audience: Shopify is a popular choice for beginners, new e-commerce businesses, and users looking for a user-friendly platform with diverse sales channels.
  • Key features: Shopify’s ease of use makes it a favorite for new entrepreneurs. It boasts a user-friendly interface and a massive app store filled with thousands of apps to expand your store’s functionality. Shopify also excels in its support for diverse sales channels, including dropshipping, and provides smooth scalability as your business grows.

Wix

  • Target audience: Wix caters to small to medium-sized businesses, freelancers, and entrepreneurs who need a versatile and easy-to-use platform.
  • Key features: Wix is known for its drag-and-drop website builder that allows users to create custom websites without coding. It offers a variety of e-commerce tools, including customizable online store templates, inventory management, and secure payment gateways. Wix also provides integrated marketing features, such as email campaigns and SEO tools, making it a well-rounded choice for users seeking an all-in-one solution.

Detailed Comparison

Now, let’s dive deeper into a side-by-side comparison of these three platforms, exploring the nuances that differentiate them:

Pricing

  • Squarespace: Offers personal plans starting at $16/month and business plans starting at $26/month. E-commerce plans begin at $30/month and go up to $46/month for advanced features.
  • BigCommerce: Starts with “Essentials” plans ranging from $39/month to $299/month, offering increasing sales limits and features. Enterprise plans, designed for high-volume businesses, come with custom pricing based on individual needs.
  • Shopify: Offers a “Lite” plan at $9/month for selling on social media or embedding a buy button. Basic plans range from $39/month to $399/month, similar to BigCommerce. Shopify Plus, their enterprise solution, starts at approximately $2,000/month.
  • Wix: E-commerce plans start at $27/month, with options going up to $59/month for VIP features. Custom pricing is available for enterprise-level solutions.

Important Considerations:

  • While the initial monthly costs appear similar for BigCommerce and Shopify, it’s crucial to factor in transaction fees. Shopify charges additional transaction fees if you choose not to use their native payment gateway, Shopify Payments. BigCommerce does not charge any transaction fees, regardless of the payment gateway you select.
  • Both Shopify and BigCommerce offer a 14-day free trial, allowing you to explore their platforms before committing. Squarespace provides a 14-day free trial for websites and a 6-month free trial for custom domains. Wix offers a free plan with limited features and a 14-day money-back guarantee on premium plans.

Ease of Use

  • Squarespace: Known for its modern and visually appealing templates, Squarespace can have a slight learning curve for those unfamiliar with website builders. However, its interface is generally considered user-friendly.
  • BigCommerce: May initially appear complex for beginners due to its extensive feature set. However, it provides a well-structured dashboard and comprehensive support resources.
  • Shopify: Designed with simplicity in mind, Shopify offers a truly intuitive drag-and-drop interface, making it exceptionally user-friendly, even for users with no prior experience in website building.
  • Wix: Offers one of the most user-friendly interfaces with its drag-and-drop editor, making it accessible for users with no coding experience. The platform also provides an AI-driven design assistant to help you get started quickly.

Design & Templates

  • Squarespace: Excels in design with a curated collection of award-winning templates known for their modern aesthetics and mobile responsiveness. Customization options within templates are available, but they might be somewhat limited compared to other platforms.
  • BigCommerce: Offers a wide variety of free and paid themes, but they may not be as visually striking as Squarespace’s templates. However, BigCommerce provides extensive customization capabilities, allowing for a high degree of design flexibility.
  • Shopify: Provides a vast theme library with free and paid options, catering to various industries and styles. While design customization is possible, Shopify’s primary strength lies in its user-friendly theme editor, simplifying the customization process.
  • Wix: Boasts a comprehensive library of customizable templates, suitable for various business types. Wix’s drag-and-drop interface allows for complete design flexibility, enabling users to create unique and visually appealing sites.

Features

  • Squarespace: While Squarespace offers essential e-commerce functionalities, its primary focus remains on website building, making it more suitable for businesses with a content-driven approach or those with limited online sales. Its built-in tools for payroll, taxes, and invoicing make it a strong choice for brick-and-mortar businesses.
  • BigCommerce: Boasts a comprehensive set of built-in e-commerce features, minimizing the need for third-party integrations. Standout native features include robust product management capabilities, multi-currency support, advanced discount rules, and powerful marketing and SEO tools.
  • Shopify: Offers a solid foundation of core e-commerce features. While some advanced features require app integrations, Shopify’s massive app store provides access to thousands of apps, covering virtually any functionality you might need. Shopify is known for its excellent dropshipping support, making it a popular choice for businesses utilizing that fulfillment model.
  • Wix: Provides a range of e-commerce features, including inventory management, secure payment options, and integrated marketing tools. Wix also offers Wix Stores, a dedicated solution for managing and promoting your online store, making it a versatile option for small to medium-sized businesses.

Scalability

  • Squarespace: While Squarespace allows for business growth, its scalability may be limited for high-volume online stores with extensive product catalogs and complex requirements.
  • BigCommerce: Specifically designed for scalability, BigCommerce can handle high traffic and large sales volumes with ease. Its enterprise-grade infrastructure and powerful features make it an excellent choice for businesses anticipating rapid growth.
  • Shopify: Offers scalability for growing businesses, but as your store expands, you may find yourself relying on an increasing number of apps, potentially adding complexity and costs. Shopify Plus, their enterprise solution, addresses the needs of high-volume businesses with dedicated support and advanced features.
  • Wix: Suitable for small to medium-sized businesses, Wix provides scalability options with its premium plans. However, it may not be as robust as BigCommerce or Shopify for large-scale enterprise needs.

Security

  • Squarespace: Provides a secure platform with built-in SSL certificates and adherence to industry standards.
  • BigCommerce: Offers a highly secure environment with robust security measures, including Level 1 PCI DSS compliance, DDOS protection, and 99.99% uptime.
  • Shopify: Includes essential security features, such as SSL certificates and fraud analysis tools.
  • Wix: Ensures a secure shopping experience with SSL encryption and compliance with industry security standards.

Key Takeaway: All three platforms prioritize security and offer a safe environment for your online business. However, BigCommerce’s enterprise-grade security infrastructure provides an added layer of protection, particularly attractive for businesses handling sensitive customer data.

The AI Revolution: Mixo

Emerging as a potential game-changer in web design, Mixo harnesses the power of AI to simplify website creation. It’s an AI-powered website builder that allows users to generate stunning landing pages within minutes, simply by describing their business idea in natural language.

Mixo represents a significant step towards democratizing web design, empowering entrepreneurs to establish a compelling online presence without requiring technical expertise or coding skills.

Which Platform is Right for You?

Choosing the “best” platform depends on your specific business requirements and goals. Here’s a quick guide to help you navigate the decision:

  • Brick-and-mortar stores with minimal online needs: Squarespace is an excellent choice due to its integrated tools for payroll, taxes, and invoicing, coupled with sleek and professional designs.
  • Users with web development experience: WooCommerce, built on WordPress, offers unparalleled flexibility and customization.
  • Most other users: BigCommerce stands out as a solid default option due to its extensive built-in features and the absence of transaction fees, minimizing reliance on third-party apps.
  • Users who need specific plugins: Shopify’s massive app store boasts thousands of apps, making it ideal for users requiring specialized functionalities.
  • If hiring an agency: WooCommerce is often the preferred choice for agencies due to its extensive customization capabilities and the abundance of skilled WordPress developers.

Factors to Consider Before Making a Final Decision:

  • Budget: Assess your budget and factor in not only the monthly costs but also any potential transaction fees, app subscriptions, and development expenses.
  • Technical Skills: Evaluate your technical comfort level. Shopify is ideal for beginners, while BigCommerce may require some learning for those new to e-commerce platforms. WooCommerce is best suited for users comfortable with WordPress or those willing to work with developers.
  • Scalability: Consider your future growth plans. BigCommerce and Shopify Plus are designed to handle high sales volumes and traffic, while Squarespace may be more suitable for smaller businesses.
  • Features: Identify your essential features and evaluate which platform offers them natively or through app integrations.
  • Support: Explore the support resources available for each platform, including documentation, tutorials, and customer service channels.

FAQ Section

What are the biggest drawbacks of using Shopify?

Shopify charges transaction fees if you don’t use Shopify Payments, their integrated payment gateway. While Shopify boasts a user-friendly interface, customization beyond their theme editor can require coding or app integrations, potentially adding complexity and costs.

Does BigCommerce offer more native features than Shopify?

Yes, BigCommerce typically provides a more extensive set of built-in e-commerce features right out of the box. This can be a significant advantage, reducing your reliance on third-party apps and potentially saving on costs and complexity.

Can I easily switch platforms if I choose the wrong one initially?

Migrating platforms can be a complex process. While tools exist to assist with data migration, it’s not always seamless. It’s best to carefully evaluate your needs and choose a platform with long-term potential to minimize the need for platform switching.

What is the best platform for a business with a very limited budget?

For businesses with limited budgets, Squarespace offers attractive personal plans at lower price points. However, if you require robust e-commerce functionalities, Shopify’s “Lite” plan, focusing on social selling and buy buttons, can be a cost-effective option.

What are the essential features I should look for in an e-commerce platform?

Essential features to consider include:

  • Product Management: Capabilities to easily add, categorize, and manage your products, including variants and inventory tracking.
  • Secure Checkout: A safe and PCI-compliant checkout process to protect customer data and build trust.
  • Marketing Tools: Features for email marketing, SEO optimization, and social media integration.
  • Shipping and Fulfillment Options: Flexible options to manage shipping rates, carriers, and fulfillment methods.
  • Analytics and Reporting: Tools to track sales, customer behavior, and overall store performance.

Remember: Choosing an e-commerce platform is a crucial decision, impacting the growth and success of your online business. Take the time to explore free trials, demos, and resources to make an informed choice that aligns with your vision.