How The RealReal Ensures Authenticity: Behind the Scenes

How The RealReal Ensures Authenticity: Behind the Scenes

by

The luxury resale market is booming. As consumers become more conscious of sustainability and seek out unique, high-quality pieces at accessible prices, platforms like The RealReal have emerged as key players. However, this surge in popularity also brings challenges, with authenticity being a top concern for buyers and sellers alike. The RealReal, one of the world’s largest online marketplaces for pre-owned luxury goods, has long positioned itself as a trusted source for authentic designer items, vigorously defending its multi-layered authentication process. This commitment to selling only genuine luxury goods has been central to their brand identity and their appeal to a discerning clientele. However, recent controversies surrounding their authentication practices have underlined the need for greater transparency and have brought the complex world of luxury authentication into the spotlight.

This blog post aims to provide an in-depth look at The RealReal’s authentication process, examining each step in detail and exploring the specialized techniques employed by their expert team.

Table of Contents

I. A Multi-Layered Authentication Process

The RealReal has established a rigorous, multi-step authentication process that aims to weed out counterfeits and ensure the authenticity of every item listed on its platform. This process involves a combination of expert human evaluation and specialized technological tools. Let’s delve into each step:

Step 1: Initial Screening

The authentication journey begins when a consignor submits an item for sale through The RealReal’s online platform. This submission includes detailed photographs of the item and a description provided by the consignor. The RealReal’s team conducts an initial review of these submissions, carefully examining the images and descriptions to identify any red flags that might indicate a potential counterfeit. This initial screening process focuses on quickly identifying obvious fakes or items that do not fall within the platform’s accepted categories. Items that clearly deviate from established brand standards, display poor craftsmanship, or bear suspect markings are rejected at this stage.

Step 2: In-Person Examination

If an item passes the initial online screening, it’s shipped to one of The RealReal’s secure warehouses for a more comprehensive examination. Here, a team of trained authenticators specializing in various luxury categories conduct a meticulous physical inspection of each item. The RealReal employs a diverse range of specialists, from handbag experts to watchmakers, gemologists, and apparel connoisseurs, ensuring that each item is assessed by a professional with the relevant expertise. These trained eyes scrutinize the items for subtle details—stitching patterns, hardware markings, material composition, and other characteristics—that are difficult to discern from photographs alone.

II. Inside the Gem Lab: Authenticating Fine Jewelry

Fine jewelry, particularly pieces that may not bear prominent brand markings, requires a specialized approach to authentication. At The RealReal, this process takes place in their dedicated Gem Lab, a space equipped with advanced tools and led by a team of highly trained gemologists. Adriana Krakowski, The RealReal’s Expert Team Lead for Fine Jewelry & Watches, plays a crucial role in this meticulous process. With a background in gemology and a Master’s degree in Modern Art, Connoisseurship, and the History of the Art Market, Krakowski brings a unique combination of scientific and artistic expertise to her role.

Let’s take a closer look at the specialized equipment Krakowski and her team utilize:

Specialized Equipment

  • Diamond Grading Lamp: This specialized lamp provides a consistent, controlled lighting environment, adhering to the standards set by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), allowing for accurate assessment of a diamond’s color. The lamp emits a specific type of fluorescent light that reveals the subtle color variations within a diamond, which might be difficult to detect under normal lighting conditions.
  • Gem Microscope: This powerful tool allows gemologists to examine gemstones under high magnification, revealing internal characteristics that are invisible to the naked eye. This microscopic examination is crucial for detecting any treatments or flaws that might indicate a fake gemstone. For example, gemologists can identify laser drill holes, which are used to remove inclusions in diamonds and decrease their value, leading to the item’s rejection.
  • Acid Testing: A traditional and reliable method for verifying the karat of gold, silver, and platinum. When hallmarks are absent or questionable, acid testing provides a definitive way to determine the purity of the metal. Different karat gold reacts differently to specific acid solutions. By observing the reaction, or lack thereof, gemologists can accurately determine the karat of the piece.
  • Refractometer: This instrument measures the refractive index of a gemstone, a crucial property that helps identify its type. Each gemstone has a unique refractive index, and this measurement provides a scientific way to confirm the authenticity of a stone.

III. Addressing the Controversies: A Balanced Perspective

While The RealReal has emphasized its commitment to authenticity and its multi-layered authentication process, a CNBC investigation raised concerns about certain aspects of their practices. The investigation suggested that not all items were authenticated by experts as claimed. Internal documents obtained by CNBC showed numerous counterfeit items being listed and sold on the platform. The investigation also revealed that copywriters, who were primarily responsible for writing product descriptions, were sometimes involved in the authentication process, despite lacking the necessary expertise. Moreover, it was reported that these copywriters had aggressive daily quotas to meet, potentially leading to a prioritization of speed over accuracy.

In response to these findings, The RealReal has taken measures to address the concerns. The company removed its “100% authentic” claim from its website and Facebook page, acknowledging the challenges associated with achieving absolute perfection in the realm of luxury authentication. While declining multiple interview requests from CNBC initially, the CEO later admitted on Mad Money that it is impossible to be perfect, implying the company cannot guarantee 100% authenticity on every item.

The investigation and subsequent response highlight the complex interplay between transparency and business practices. While consumers demand greater transparency into authentication processes, luxury resellers must also protect their proprietary methods from potential exploitation by counterfeiters.

The investigation undoubtedly impacted consumer trust. It raised questions about the reliability of The RealReal’s authentication processes and underscored the importance of consumer vigilance when purchasing luxury goods online.

IV. Tips for Buyers: Ensuring Authentic Purchases

As the luxury resale market continues to expand, it’s crucial for buyers to be informed and take proactive steps to ensure the authenticity of their purchases. While platforms like The RealReal have established procedures to vet items, ultimately, well-informed consumers play a significant role in combating counterfeits. Here are some essential tips for buyers:

  • Research and Compare: Thorough research is paramount. Before committing to a purchase, scrutinize the item thoroughly, comparing prices, descriptions, and photographs across multiple platforms and reliable sources. Exercise caution with deals that appear too good to be true, as these often serve as a red flag for potential counterfeits. Familiarize yourself with the specific details of authentic items, such as stitching patterns, hardware markings, and material composition, enabling you to identify inconsistencies.
  • Check Seller Reputation: Always take the seller’s reputation into account. Look for established sellers with positive ratings, favorable reviews, and clear, consumer-friendly return policies. Reputable platforms like The RealReal have systems in place to verify seller identities and track their performance, providing a level of consumer protection.
  • Ask Questions: Don’t hesitate to contact the seller directly with any questions or concerns you may have about an item’s authenticity. Reputable sellers will be transparent and willing to provide additional information or address your inquiries. If a seller is evasive or reluctant to answer your questions, it’s advisable to proceed with caution.
  • Utilize The RealReal’s Resources: The RealReal offers various resources to educate consumers about authentication. Their blog features articles focused on identifying counterfeit items across diverse categories, while their website offers expert advice on spotting fakes. Taking advantage of these resources can empower you with the knowledge to make more informed purchasing decisions.

V. FAQ: Common Questions About The RealReal’s Authentication

What happens if an item I buy from The RealReal turns out to be fake?

The RealReal stands behind the authenticity of the items it sells and provides a comprehensive return policy and a money-back guarantee. If an item you purchase is later determined to be non-authentic, you have the right to return it for a full refund.

Do all items sold on The RealReal go through the gem lab?

The gem lab is specifically dedicated to authenticating fine jewelry and watches. Other categories, such as handbags, apparel, and accessories, are subjected to specialized authentication processes conducted by experts with specific knowledge in those areas.

How can I trust The RealReal after the CNBC investigation?

The CNBC investigation raised legitimate concerns about specific aspects of The RealReal’s authentication practices. However, the company has taken steps to address those concerns, including the removal of the “100% authentic” claim, a move that reflects a more nuanced and transparent approach to authentication. They have also emphasized their commitment to ongoing improvement and the implementation of more robust authentication measures. Consumers are encouraged to stay informed and to leverage the resources and information available to make well-considered purchasing decisions in the luxury resale market.